The Life Reef Skimmer Club

[bayoupr]

Should have my iwaki 40rt(jap motor) next week. looking forward to seeing the pressure rated difference!

I don't think you are going to be happy with that pump on a 24" unless you choke the pump output back.

[FranktheTankTx]

It's going to be the same thing as a result of the most important part of the largest one. The only thing that you can get is the best pump and the rest are not an intended recipient of this application.

[rEeFnWrX]

Originally Posted by bayoupr

I don't think you are going to be happy with that pump on a 24" unless you choke the pump output back.

Yep, I'll have a gate valve for the outlet. I'd rather get something slightly more powerful in case I upgrade to a 30" or 36". Keep in mind, I have the stock venturi.

[bayoupr]

Yep, I'll have a gate valve for the outlet. I'd rather get something slightly more powerful in case I upgrade to a 30" or 36". Keep in mind, I have the stock venturi.

If you do upgrade to a 36" that pump would work great. I am running the Panworld 100PX which equal to that pump on my 36". The only thing I have to do is throttle down the air draw. Like to know how it runs with the stock venturi.

[rEeFnWrX]

Originally Posted by bayoupr

If you do upgrade to a 36" that pump would work great. I am running the Panworld 100PX which equal to that pump on my 36". The only thing I have to do is throttle down the air draw. Like to know how it runs with the stock venturi.

Yep. Wattage will be nice with it throttled back too

Was thinking about plumbing 1" for the inlet and reducing to 3/4" right before the pump... Any thoughts?

[bayoupr]

Was thinking about plumbing 1" for the inlet and reducing to 3/4" right before the pump... Any thoughts?

Mine is 1" plumbing to the pump which has a 1-3/4" reducer due to the pump having 3/4" mpt

[Piper27]

I got tired of cleaning my neck every other day so I brought my collection cup and visited with Justin at avast and got a swabbie. The micro blade is the right one that fits this neck. The 6" top came with screws that bottom out so I will have to talk with him and get longer ones. Also the blade on the micro wiper needs to be sent out long and you should cut it yourself. It is floppy at points because the wiper base is so snall but seems like it will be stiff enough to clean it, even though there is no support on the ends We will see
It says to run for 15 min. 4 times a day but I am running it all day til I can find a new timer. That way I can see how well it works. Its not interfering with the bubbles, its just making them spin around the cup slowly til they fall over. I am guessing my cup will completely fill in a day now. It used to fill halfway up in one day. I will need the auto shut off and bucket setup for this now. I can't wait til its setup and I will rarely have to touch it!

[Piper27]

[shermanator]

I have a SVS-30 and a lifereef sump. Neither are setup yet (I've been taking forever to do my new install) and have two questions:

1) My sump is setup to have the skimmer internal or external. Sump is in the basement, so I have room for either way. Aside from pump selection (which is question #2), is there any advantage to either setup? I am planning to go with internal as a safety measure (in case of flood, better to be in sump), but if there is a performance advantage to doing external, I might go that route.

2) I have a Mag12, but I see a lot of posts in this thread using a Mag18 for the 30". Assuming I leave the skimmer internal, should I go with the Mag18 for better performance with the 30"? I know I'd be looking at a BlueLine (BL 30HDX, or similar) pump if I put the skimmer external.

Thanks!

[EvMiBo]

I think the general consensus is that the pressure rated external pumps provide the best overall performance. As far as submersible pumps it seems to be tough to beat the mags (I'd go mag18 over the mag12), but people have also used laguna maxflows, jebaos, and some others. You can have the best of both worlds though, just drill the sump so you can plumb to and from the external pump, while the skimmer stays in the sump. I've flirted with the idea of doing this, but for now will be giving the jebao dc9000 a shot on the 30" body (finally being delivered today!). If I had a basement like you do I wouldn't hesitate to do what I mentioned above.

[shermanator]

Originally Posted by EvMiBo

You can have the best of both worlds though, just drill the sump so you can plumb to and from the external pump, while the skimmer stays in the sump.

Thanks -- This sounds like a great idea! And it never crossed my mind, but it's a perfect solution.

I've had the sump and skimmer since June and at the rate I am going with the new tank, it'll be next spring before I have it up and running (or maybe I'll make some progress around the holidays, fingers crossed).

For a 30" external, is the BL 30HDX the best bet? Or worth the slight upgrade to the 40 HDX?

[EvMiBo]

Originally Posted by shermanator

Thanks -- This sounds like a great idea! And it never crossed my mind, but it's a perfect solution.

I've had the sump and skimmer since June and at the rate I am going with the new tank, it'll be next spring before I have it up and running (or maybe I'll make some progress around the holidays, fingers crossed).

For a 30" external, is the BL 30HDX the best bet? Or worth the slight upgrade to the 40 HDX?

Just make sure you get that Aluminum experiment finished. As I mentioned in the other thread I'm very interested in the results.

As far as which external pump I can only say that the BL/Panworld 30HDX is what lifereef recommends. But these bodies can handle more, for example Jeff uses a mag12 on his 24" body whereas the website recommends a mag9. I have no experience so far with the external pumps but many in the thread do. I have a strong feeling it could handle more than the 30HD, but I don't know if the 40HD or 40HDX would be better for the skimmer. The HD's have higher max. head pressures/lower outputs and the HDX's have a higher output/lower max. head pressure, if that makes sense.

I've followed this thread since June, you think I would know the answer to that.

Here's an AquaCave link for pump comparison details. I think we should let the more seasoned LR'ers chime in though. Finally, the japanese motor Iwaki's are slightly quieter and consume slightly less wattage, but they are more expensive as well. Many choice here!

[shermanator]

Originally Posted by EvMiBo

Just make sure you get that Aluminum experiment finished. As I mentioned in the other thread I'm very interested in the results.

As far as which external pump I can only say that the BL/Panworld 30HDX is what lifereef recommends. But these bodies can handle more, for example Jeff uses a mag12 on his 24" body whereas the website recommends a mag9. I have no experience so far with the external pumps but many in the thread do. I have a strong feeling it could handle more than the 30HD, but I don't know if the 40HD or 40HDX would be better for the skimmer. The HD's have higher max. head pressures/lower outputs and the HDX's have a higher output/lower max. head pressure, if that makes sense.

I've followed this thread since June, you think I would know the answer to that.

Here's an AquaCave link for pump comparison details. I think we should let the more seasoned LR'ers chime in though. Finally, the japanese motor Iwaki's are slightly quieter and consume slightly less wattage, but they are more expensive as well. Many choice here!

A grad student is going to do the aluminum testing, so my aquarium distractions won't effect the speed of those results. =)

I get lost in all the pressure rated vs not (and the subsequent BlueLine designation). I know (think?) the venturi is causing the need for pressure, but when I'm looking at pressure vs head height I get lost in how that relates to a skimmer. And I'm always confused why Jeff recommends the HD-X pumps if everyone here says the pressure rated HD pumps are superior (but I believe the masses).

I don't mind the BlueLine because they are relatively cheap and seem to last forever (and my electricity costs are low).

I'll just defer to whatever the LR experts say... anyone else have an opinion on the best external pump for a VS-30? Thanks!

[shermanator]

Oh, and if it matters, my VS-30 has the mazzei venturi.

[Piper27]

Originally Posted by Piper27

This thing works great, there is no gunk on my neck and it is not built up on the blade either. I think running it continuously is helping it. Its not disturbing bubbles and hopefully I will not have to clean it for a good while. Keep you guys updated.

[azjohnny]

IMO a non pressure pump gets good results, if you need to turn down the incoming air with a needle valve whats the use of going with a pressure pump ( the reason of going with a pressure pump is to draw more air)

I have a VS3-36 with a Fluval Seas SP4 and a Mazzei 1078 and very happy with the results and its still stable.

By drawing more you are messing with the balance of the skimmer and you can get inconsistent skimming ( if you are getting more than 1.5" of foam below the flange it will be unstable)

[Adam G]

Been skimming for a several weeks now and all is good. Using the Laguna Max flow 2000 on the 30" skimmer and am happy with the results. Being the OCD reefer that I am I want to make sure that I am getting the most out of my skimmer. Here is a pic of my my Dwyer meter results about 20 to 21 SCFH:



Getting good amounts of skimmate as you can see here. This is 3 days worth on my 150g:



As you can see I cam skimming a bit wet. The skimmate is Dark Tea color.

So the question I have to ask is am I getting maximum results with 20 SCFH or should I be trying to achieve more with a different pump? Anyone find they get more skimming with higher SCFH? I am using the 978 Mazzei Venuri. If more air equals more skim I will go ahead and try Mag 18 and see what it pulls and see how it does. If other have found 20 SCFH to be a sweet spot for the 30" than I will tell myself that I am good and leave it alone!

[bayoupr]

I would leave it. Anything much higher than 20scfh makes the foam head unstable.

[EvMiBo]

I picked up kris101's 30" LR a couple weeks ago. And my jebao dc9000 was delivered yesterday

I have pretty limited sump space, my "skimmer section" is pretty small at 11"x11". Instead of cramping everything into the section, which would make getting to my fileter socks a headache, I decided to plumb it so that the pump will stay in the larger return section, where I have more space available. I hard plumbed it today and have it in a vinegar bath right now. Do you all think my plumbing will be alright? I was kind of conerned about 90 + 2 45 elbows... Also, the gate valve will be about 1.5" underwater, I know this has been discussed before somewhere, but just wanted to make sure there won't be much of a back pressure issue? If necessary I can pull up the pipe so that the gate valve exit is slightly out of water... The pictures are about 5 minutes after firing everything up, already cleaning the inside of the body (picture 4)!

[azjohnny]

Originally Posted by EvMiBo

I picked up kris101's 30" LR a couple weeks ago. And my jebao dc9000 was delivered yesterday

I have pretty limited sump space, my "skimmer section" is pretty small at 11"x11". Instead of cramping everything into the section, which would make getting to my fileter socks a headache, I decided to plumb it so that the pump will stay in the larger return section, where I have more space available. I hard plumbed it today and have it in a vinegar bath right now. Do you all think my plumbing will be alright? I was kind of conerned about 90 + 2 45 elbows... Also, the gate valve will be about 1.5" underwater, I know this has been discussed before somewhere, but just wanted to make sure there won't be much of a back pressure issue? If necessary I can pull up the pipe so that the gate valve exit is slightly out of water... The pictures are about 5 minutes after firing everything up, already cleaning the inside of the body (picture 4)!

You will have no problems with back pressure having the gate valve under water. There will be some back pressure but you just adjust the gate valve to compensate. I have a 90 degree elbow with my design and no issues

Here is a pic of mine before I installed it in the sump

[EvMiBo]

Good to hear, that's what I was thinking. Too lazy to go searching right now

[rEeFnWrX]

Originally Posted by EvMiBo

I picked up kris101's 30" LR a couple weeks ago. And my jebao dc9000 was delivered yesterday

I have pretty limited sump space, my "skimmer section" is pretty small at 11"x11". Instead of cramping everything into the section, which would make getting to my fileter socks a headache, I decided to plumb it so that the pump will stay in the larger return section, where I have more space available. I hard plumbed it today and have it in a vinegar bath right now. Do you all think my plumbing will be alright? I was kind of conerned about 90 + 2 45 elbows... Also, the gate valve will be about 1.5" underwater, I know this has been discussed before somewhere, but just wanted to make sure there won't be much of a back pressure issue? If necessary I can pull up the pipe so that the gate valve exit is slightly out of water... The pictures are about 5 minutes after firing everything up, already cleaning the inside of the body (picture 4)!

You want to add a section of silicon or vinyl tubing. Jeff won't warranty any skimmer that is hard plumbed 100% to the pump.

Also, there is no issue with back pressure during normal operation with the gate valve underwater.

However, if your sump water level rises or falls due to the outlet from the skimmer body being under water you may see fluctuation in skimming performance... water rises in sump you will skim wetter, water drops in sump, you will skim dryer...

This is not because of back pressure. This is because since your water level is where the outlet is right from the skimmer body. When the water rises or falls in the sump your static base water level in the skimmer will also rise or fall.

If your skimmer outlet is above your water level at all times. the sump water leveling rising or falling will never affect your skimming

[EvMiBo]

Thanks. The skimmer section water level doesn't change, the return section does (where the pump will be).

That's kind of a bummer about the hard plumbing voiding the warranty. I'd have to rebuild most of the plumbing since all slip plumbing is glued. I guess I should email Jeff anyway since I'm the second owner and all.

[gar732]

I've got a couple questions for you guys, I'm looking to join the club. I'm thinking about picking up an svs3-24 for an approximately 140 gallon grow out system for my clowns. I'm not 100% sure what I'm going to use for a sump so it might go up or down by 10-20 gallons. There will be heavy feeding and a large bio load. Do you guys think this skimmer would be a good fit? Also will an ehiem 1262 be a good pump for that skimmer, I have this pump already. The system may grow by another 100 gallons in the future at which point I would buy an extention for the skimmer and go with a bigger pump, but that would be a little while before that happens. And lastly could anyone tell me what the ID of the neck is and how tall the stock cup is? Thanks

[rEeFnWrX]

Originally Posted by EvMiBo

Thanks. The skimmer section water level doesn't change, the return section does (where the pump will be).

That's kind of a bummer about the hard plumbing voiding the warranty. I'd have to rebuild most of the plumbing since all slip plumbing is glued. I guess I should email Jeff anyway since I'm the second owner and all.

Just use a PVC cutter and glue on a 3/4" female slip x female threaded... then a 3/4" hose barb then attach silicone tube to another hosr barb on the pump and you are gtg...